Comfort-care model respects God’s sovereignty to the end - Catholic Courier
Sign up today for up to 3 free weekly newsletters
Watch and subscribe on YouTube
Courier photos make great gifts!
A woman puts linens on a hospital bed.

Mt. Carmel House staff member Ana Burgado makes a bed at the house in Hilton Aug. 21. (Courier photo by Jeff Witherow)

Comfort-care model respects God’s sovereignty to the end

Forty years ago, Deacon Fernando Ona, a medical doctor serving at St. Mary’s Hospital in Rochester, repeatedly witnessed what he viewed as tragic occurrences.

The hospital’s patients were dying alone.

He mentioned this pattern to his friend Father John “Jack” Healy, OCarm, spiritual director of the Rochester-area Lay Carmelites, who in turn discussed it with Lay Carmelites Rose and Raoul Grossi.

The Grossis responded with Christian charity: “We’ll take them,” Father Healy recently recalled them saying.

Thanks to the Grossis’ patronage, Mt. Carmel House — the first of its kind end-of-life comfort-care home in New York state — opened on July 16, 1984, originally on Rochester’s Lorimer Street, according to information on the home’s website, mtcarmelhouserochester.org.

Father Healy, who serves as Mt. Carmel House’s chaplain, affirmed that providing truly compassionate and personal end-of-life care acknowledges God’s rights over us, “respecting the sovereignty of God and living by his providence, right to the very end.”

Yet as Mt. Carmel House marks four decades of accompanying and caring for people at the end of life, forces in the New York State Legislature renewed a push to legalize physician-assisted suicide for people with serious or terminal illnesses.

Euthanasia and assisted suicide are ‘intrinsically evil’

Physician-assisted suicide is legal in 10 states and the District of Columbia, according to an article on medical aid in dying laws published Sept. 11 by the Journal of the American Medical Association.

In January 2024, the Medical Aid in Dying Act (A995/S2445) was introduced in both houses of the New York State Legislature, but it did not make it out of the health committees of the Senate and Assembly before the legislative session ended in June. The bill has been introduced in the Legislature every year since the 2015-16 session, according to the legislation’s version history included with S2445.

Support for New York’s bill and similar ones being proposed throughout the U.S. comes from the organization Death with Dignity, which promotes the “right to die” as an essential human right and means of promoting human dignity.

That idea is directly opposed to Catholic teaching, which holds that all human life is sacred from conception to natural death. The Catechism of the Catholic Church states that “Intentional euthanasia, whatever its forms or motives, is murder. It is gravely contrary to the dignity of the human person and to the respect due to the living God, his Creator” (No. 2324).

In 2020, Samaritanus Bonus (“The Good Samaritan”), a letter issued by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and approved by Pope Francis, reiterated that euthanasia and assisted suicide are “intrinsically evil,” echoing the Second Vatican Council’s declaration in Gaudium et Spes (“Joy and Hope”).

Pope Francis also has spoken several times about the need for comfort or palliative care, which aims to improve the quality of life for those suffering with severe or terminal illnesses.

“We must accompany people towards death, but not provoke death or facilitate assisted suicide,” the pope said during his general audience on Feb. 9, 2022.

Mt. Carmel House provides palliative care in a home-like environment

Accompanying the dying with love and compassion was the mission of St. Teresa of Calcutta, Father Healy noted, and her ministry of palliative care became the model for Mt. Carmel House.

Comfort care at Mt. Carmel House is provided free of charge, Father Healy said, and admission is based on need with preference given to those who cannot be cared for at home.

He noted that the physical, emotional and medical needs of residents at the end of life are attended to by nurses, aides and volunteers, who also support the families of the residents.

“Mt. Carmel House runs on volunteers,” Father Healy explained, noting that more volunteers are always needed.

“I love it. It’s rewarding,” Dian Fyfe said of her experiences volunteering at Mt. Carmel House.

Another volunteer, Vicky Surash, said she appreciates the training in comfort care she has received at Mt. Carmel House, as well as the community of volunteers and the individualized care provided to residents and their families.

Comfort care upholds the dignity and value of human life

It’s this one-on-one personalized care for residents and families that has most impressed Rachel Sargent, a registered nurse who came on board as director of Mt. Carmel House in June of 2024.

Sargent said that Mt. Carmel House enables family members of the dying to spend time with their loved one and process the stages of life and death while being supported in a warm, home-like environment.

She noted that Mt. Carmel House’s supportive environment for the dying and their loved ones became the model for other comfort-care homes around Rochester, including Journey House, Isaiah House, Crossroads and many others. Today, dozens of comfort-care homes have been established across New York state, according to NYcomfortcare.org.

In addition to Mt. Carmel House — which is now located on Frisbee Hill Road in Hilton — Father Healy said four other comfort-care homes are operated as ministries of the Order of Carmelites: one in Katala, India; one outside Manila, Philippines; and two in Indonesia.

“It’s necessary to have comfort-care homes, because they show the dignity and value of human life to the very end,” he said.

Tags: Deacons, End-of-Life Decisions, Life Issues, Religious Orders
Copyright © 2026 Rochester Catholic Press Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Linking is encouraged, but republishing or redistributing, including by framing or similar means, without the publisher's prior written permission is prohibited.

You May Also Enjoy

Choose from news (Monday), leisure (Thursday) or worship (Saturday) — or get all three!


No, Thanks


Catholic Courier Newsletters