Finger Lakes schools consider consolidation - Catholic Courier

Finger Lakes schools consider consolidation

Representatives from St. Patrick’s School in Seneca Falls and St. Mary’s School in Waterloo have formed a joint committee to examine the possibility of consolidation, according to Sister Elizabeth Meegan, OP, superintendent of schools for the Diocese of Rochester.

The committee, formed in December 2003, consists of both schools’ principals as well as teachers and parents from each school. It has been looking at the situation in both schools and at information from the diocesan schools office on the conditions of the buildings, said Diana Oravec, principal of St. Patrick’s. The committee has also discussed potential sites for a possible consolidated school, ways that might be used to attract new students to it, and additional programs and services it might be able to offer, said Fred Smith, principal of St. Mary’s. The committee is expected to submit a recommendation to the diocesan office this fall on whether it would be beneficial for the schools to consolidate.

“Declining enrollment is certainly an issue in both schools. The per-pupil cost is going to be higher when you have a lower enrollment,” Sister Meegan said, adding that low enrollment makes it difficult to ensure that classes will be large enough to facilitate good socialization among students.

The committee also has been looking at ways to help the staff and students get to know each other, which would ease a transition should consolidation occur, Oravec said. The schools had been working together on specific events for years, she added, even holding an annual joint Halloween party.

The collaboration became much more extensive this year, Smith said. Students met at each other’s churches for Stations of the Cross during Lent; students from both schools participated in Waterloo’s Memorial Day parade; and the students and staff of both schools met in June for a picnic and field day.

Smith said he expects the children from both schools to interact with each other even more this year, noting that such collaboration is not only good for students but also for the schools, which benefit from sharing the cost of programs.

Some of the schools’ seventh-graders had become acquainted by playing against each other in basketball, but other activities for seventh-graders — such as the Seder meal they shared with Father William Laird, St. Patrick’s pastor — are being arranged to enable students to get to know each other as more than just competitors.

“If and when the merger occurs, the kids aren’t going to be completely left in the lurch,” Oravec said. “We are working together and for the best interests of the kids. We put the kids as our No. 1 priority.”

Preserving Catholic education in Seneca County is a priority for the joint committee, she added. If preventative steps aren’t taken, both schools could fail.

“Both of the communities are very supportive of Catholic education and want to ensure the future of Catholic education,” Sister Meegan said. “It is difficult for communities that have a long history of Catholic schools to talk about things changing. Change is always difficult for people, particularly with regard to their schools, their churches, because there’s a lot of history and a lot of allegiance and love.”

Although change is difficult, people in the area are beginning to see the need to consider consolidation of the schools and the benefits it could bring, Smith said.

“You can’t keep funding and funding when your enrollment continues to drop. It’s just not cost-effective. There’s a lot more to be gained from looking at consolidation than there is to lose. People are starting to realize that,” he said.

In a letter inserted into parish bulletins, the joint committee stressed the importance of being proactive in pursuing a detailed strategic plan for possible consolidation.

“A meeting will be held in October 2004 to decide on the future of Catholic school education in our communities,” the letter said. “With the support of the families in our two parishes who already believe in the value of a Catholic education, we will be successful.”

Copyright © 2023 Rochester Catholic Press Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Linking is encouraged, but republishing or redistributing, including by framing or similar means, without the publisher's prior written permission is prohibited.

Choose from news (Monday), leisure (Thursday) or worship (Saturday) — or get all three!

No, Thanks

Catholic Courier Newsletters