PITTSFORD — New York state’s recent legalization of physician-assisted suicide promises to create a host of pastoral challenges for Catholic clergy and laypeople alike, according to Canadian writer and speaker Amanda Achtman, a professor of Catholic bioethics with St. Bernard’s School of Theology and Ministry and a leading critic of Canada’s medical assistance in dying program.
“In Canada, I hear from priests regularly in all different provinces who are being touched by this, in the administration of the sacraments, around funerals, with their parishioners,” Achtman told a gathering of priests and deacons at St. Bernard’s Oct. 17.
New York’s Medical Aid in Dying Act, which took effect Aug. 5, allows a terminally ill adult with a prognosis of six months or less to request from a physician medication that would hasten his or her death, if the patient decided to take it.
New York’s Catholic bishops, including Bishop John S. Bonnici and Bishop Emeritus Salvatore R. Matano, had spoken out against the legislation in the months leading up to its passage. Now, Bishop Bonnici said at the Oct. 17 gathering, their work moves into a new phase.
“The reality is, it’s law, and now we need to deal with it as ministers, as individuals who are called every single day to go forward and to care for God’s holy people,” he said.
Canada’s decade of experience with assisted suicide, euthanasia
Euthanasia was legalized in Canada in 2016 and now accounts for one in every 20 deaths in that nation, according to Achtman, who previously worked with a Canadian Parliament member in an effort to prevent the expansion of euthanasia within Canada.
While New York’s law mandates that patients who choose physician-assisted suicide must self-administer the life-ending drugs, in Canada, the term “medical assistance in dying” encompasses both the self-administration of life-ending drugs and their direct provision by a doctor or nurse practitioner via lethal injection, Achtman said. In 2024 — the most recent year for which data is available — 100 percent of the 16,499 patients who died by so-called MAiD opted for lethal injection, she said, citing a 2025 report from Canada’s health department.
“If you have to self-administer, that’s a massive deterrent. Many people would not be able to bring themselves to do it, but if a doctor or nurse practitioner will do it for you, you have the mutual outsourcing of responsibility. The doctor says I’m simply fulfilling the patient’s wishes, and the patient says I’m simply undergoing a medical procedure that’s legal,” said Achtman, who works in ethics education for Canadian Physicians for Life.
Although medical professionals cannot legally administer lethal injections to patients in New York, Achtman cautioned local Catholics against thinking such actions would never be permissible in this state. She cited the hypothetical example of someone with a disability suing the state, claiming he or she is not receiving equal treatment because he or she isn’t able to self-administer the drugs, and “you can see how the trajectory would change,” she said. If people claim that euthanasia is a reasonable, compassionate means to end suffering, then it’s no surprise that they would eventually seek to expand access to ever-widening categories of people, she said.
“If it is a ‘good thing,’ then it becomes a question of access, and that’s exactly how in 2021 Canada expanded euthanasia on the basis of disability and mental illness,” said Achtman, who founded a cultural renewal project called Dying to Meet You, which is meant to humanize the cultural conversation on suffering, death, meaning and hope.
Assisted suicide, euthanasia lead to dehumanization
The simple act of establishing criteria is more of a problem than it is a safeguard, Achtman said.
“By simply having criteria by which there is a category of human beings who could just not exist, that itself is dehumanizing. That’s why I would stress that this concerns absolutely everyone, even those who don’t opt for it,” she said. “Being told that you fit a category that qualifies you for suicide assistance rather than suicide prevention, that makes you eligible for state-sponsored suicide … already deflates and defeats a person’s sense of self.”
The top 5 reasons people in Canada opt for euthanasia all relate to individuals’ loss of dignity, autonomy and the ability to participate in meaningful activities or daily self-care, Achtman said. For many people, the decision stems from the fear of being a burden to others, of being abandoned by loved ones or of dying alone, she said.
“All of these issues, pastorally, are just beneath the surface,” Achtman said.
Pastoral response to those considering assisted suicide
Knowing how to respond pastorally to these issues and to people considering euthanasia can be challenging, she added. Achtman said several different groups of Canadian bishops have released documents providing guidelines relating to the celebration of the sacraments with people and families considering or opting for assisted suicide or euthanasia. She cited the document created by the Catholic Bishops of Alberta and the Northwest Territories as a particularly helpful document.
However, the answers to questions regarding the sacraments are very nuanced, she said.
“They require knowing the person a lot of times in order to make judgments about their circumstances and about the nature of what they may be discerning,” Achtman said.
One thing about which the Canadian bishops have been very clear, however, is the fact that Catholics may not be with an individual at the moment that euthanasia is administered, lest their presence be seen as a sign of support for the act, she said.
“Catholics are deeply confused about this,” she said, noting that many have told her they thought being present with an individual in his or her last moments would be a way of showing love. “The consistent approach so far has been, you can be there up until the point of and absolutely not at all during the act, and everything should be given to resist it. … You want to say, ‘I will be with you as long as I can, but I cannot be with you if you go through with this.’”
Connection with Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament
While the Catholic Church is oftentimes known for saying “no” about such matters as euthanasia and abortion that conflict with church teaching, the Catholic bishops of the Saskatchewan province recently suggested Catholics need “to be bolder in their “yes” to such things as palliative care and accompaniment, Achtman said. Catholics should encourage hope and try to dispel the dehumanization so common in today’s world, she said.
For example, people who are fearful of being unable to participate in meaningful activities or of being forgotten by those around them sometimes take solace in being reminded of Jesus making himself present to us in the Blessed Sacrament in the tabernacle.
“You will never become more frail, more dependent, more weak or vulnerable or hidden or unspoken or even ignored than our Lord makes himself to you in the Blessed Sacrament, and this can become a basis for identification and intimacy with Christ,” Achtman said.
Tags: Bishop John S. Bonnici, End-of-Life Decisions, Life Issues, NY Catholics


